Sotheby’s sue over fake Parmigianino

Sotheby’s has filed a lawsuit in New York against the vendor of a 16th century Old Master painting after it was confirmed to be a fake.

In October last year, the auction house announced it would be conducting an investigation into the painting of ‘Saint Jerome’. Attributed to the ‘Circle of Parmigianino’, it was sold by Sotheby’s New York in January 2012 for US$800,000 (£509,650). Doubts over the work’s authenticity emerged after it was linked to an Old Master forgery scandal, which broke last year.  Continue reading

Tate announces appointment of new director Maria Balshaw

Maria Balshaw’s appointment as the new director of Tate was confirmed today after receiving the Prime Minister’s approval. Announcing the appointment, Chairman of the Trustees of Tate, Lord Browne, said Balshaw has “the vision, drive and stature to lead Tate into its next phase of development”.

A champion of Manchester’s cultural renaissance, Balshaw has been the director of the University of Manchester’s Whitworth Gallery since 2006, director of Manchester City Galleries since 2011, a board member of Arts Council England since 2014 and has recently assumed the role of Director of Culture for Manchester City Council.  Continue reading

Wildenstein avoids guilty verdict via French legal loophole

One of France’s biggest ever tax fraud trials was brought to a close yesterday (12 January 2017) with the acquittal of Guy Wildenstein.

The heir to the Wildenstein art-dealing empire appeared in court in Paris in September 2016 to respond to charges of tax fraud and money laundering.  Prosecutors accused him of hiding paintings and properties in trusts and offshore holding companies and failing to report the full extent of the family’s wealth following the deaths of his father Daniel in 2001 and brother Alec in 2008.  Continue reading

‘Hollyweed’ prankster arrested over New Year stunt

The artist and videographer responsible for changing the famous ‘Hollywood’ sign in Los Angeles to read ‘Hollyweed’ turned himself into the police on Monday (9 January 2017).

Security cameras recorded Zachary Cole Fernandez as he carried out the stunt on New Year’s Day. Fernandez’s creative partner and former wife Sarah Fern is also said to have been behind the work. The couple decided that Fern would be responsible for the construction and Fernandez would complete the physical installation in case one of them was arrested. “We have kids, so we didn’t want both of us to be locked up,” Fernandez said.

Fernandez openly admitted responsibility for the prank in online news outlets as well as on his Instagram account where he calls himself ‘JesusHands’. The Los Angeles Police Department only confirmed the artist’s responsibility when he voluntarily turned himself in. The artist will be released on his own recognisance and is due to appear in court on 15 February 2017.

To execute the installation, Fernandez said he had to scale some 20 feet just to reach the ladders, which are on both sides of the letters. He insists that the work was not an act of vandalism and that clamps were used to clip fabric covers in place over the letters so they could be removed easily. “We collaborated before, packed everything, trying to keep it simple and easy. I’m not about “vandalizing” things”, Fernandez said.

Responding to whether he was prepared to face the legal repercussions of his actions Fernandez said ‘sometimes in order to create that conversation, you have to be OK with the consequences’.

This is not the first time that the iconic sign has been the subject of an artistic prank. In 1976, Danny Finegood changed the sign to ‘Hollyweed’ as part of an art school project which paid tribute to the relaxation of marijuana laws in California. In homage to his predecessor, Fernandez inscribed the ‘O’ in the sign with ‘a tribute to Mr. Finegood’.

Fernandez and Fern have said they are already planning to collaborate on similar installations in future. “We’re always looking for the next thing”, Fern said.

 

Collective Ownership of Collections: When co-owners disagree

In Butler and another v Butler and another [2016] EWHC 1793 (Ch) a collector had amassed a collection of several hundred 17th century Chinese pots, valued at up to £8 million. He gave most of these to his four adult children in equal shares. This gift was made formally, by a deed, but the children themselves did not enter any written agreement governing their relationship with the collection.

The children preserved the collection for over 25 years while their father remained alive. When he died, two of the children (the Claimants) wished for the collection to be distributed amongst each of them, whereas the other two (the Defendants) wished to preserve the collection for scholarly study and exhibition. What happens to the collection in such circumstances and how does the Court decide?  Continue reading

New York antiquities dealer arrested in crackdown on illegal trafficking

Prominent New York art dealer, Nancy Wiener, was arrested last Wednesday (21 December) on suspicion of trafficking illegal Asian antiquities. According to the complaint filed in Manhattan’s Criminal Court, Wiener sold stolen objects to Sotheby’s and Christie’s auction houses, international museums and private buyers. She has been charged with criminal possession of stolen property and conspiracy to buy, smuggle and launder millions of dollars worth of antiquities from East Asia.  Continue reading

Museum threatened with lawsuit over Van Gogh sketchbook

Amsterdam’s Van Gogh Museum is facing legal action after it dismissed a sketchbook allegedly belonging to the Dutch artist as a fake.

The discovery of the album of 65 drawings purported to be by Van Gogh was made in 2013 by art historian Bogomila Welsh-Ovcharov who believes it was used by the artist on his travels in the south of France. When the drawings were unveiled at a press conference in Paris in November this year the Van Gogh Museum quickly released a statement entitled “Found Sketchbook With Drawings Is Not By Van Gogh, According to Van Gogh Museum”. Now Le Seuil, the publishing house behind Welsh-Ovcharov’s new book on the drawings “Vincent Van Gogh, the Fog of Arles: the Rediscovered Sketchbook”, has hit back at the museum by threatening to initiate a lawsuit. Continue reading

US government votes in favour of art restitution law

In a rare moment of solidarity in US politics a historic art restitution bill was passed by Congress on Friday (9 December).

Proposed in April this year, the Holocaust Expropriated Art Recovery Act (HEAR) facilitates the restitution process by which Nazi-looted art is returned to its rightful pre-war owners. The bill was backed by Republican senators Ted Cruz and John Cornyn together with Democrat Senators Charles Schumer and Richard Blumenthal. Continue reading